• Library Database vs. Search Engine(Google) vs Google Scholar

    Databases

     What is a database?

    • Library databases allow you to efficiently search for published information such as magazines, journals, and newspaper articles. Library databases can be general (all disciplines) or discipline-specific (e.g. a psychology database).

     

     

    Why use a database?

    • Reliable – Many articles found in library databases have undergone a peer review process and are generally more reliable than information found on the Internet. Additionally, databases provide all the information you need to evaluate a source for credibility (such as author name, publication details, and a summary).

     

    • Relevant – library databases allow you to customize your search to get the most relevant results. You can search using keywords, discipline-specific terminology, subject headings, and descriptors. You can also search by author, title, and limit your results using various criteria (date, source type, etc.).

     

    • Accessible – Databases often provide access to the full-text of an article, so you do not need to go to the library to retrieve it in person. Additionally, database access is purchased by libraries for its patrons, which allows you to access otherwise pricey information at no charge.

     

    What databases does the High School Library recommend for getting started?

     Search Engine

    What is a search engine?

    • A search engine, such as Google or Yahoo!, uses computer algorithms to search the Internet and identify items that match the characters and keywords entered by a user.

    Why use a search engine?

    • Search engines are useful for finding information produced by governments, organizations, groups, and individuals. Examples of reliable information you can find through a search engine include freely available statistics published by a government agency or a freely available article published by a reputable news outlet.
    • Note: It is more challenging to narrow results effectively, find relevant material, and assess the legitimacy of information in your search results when using a search engine.

     

    How do I know when I should use a search engine and when I should use a database?

    • It depends on what type of information you are hoping to find and how you plan to use it. If you want credible, scholarly articles, you will have more success finding relevant sources in a library database free of charge. If you want Census data, it is more efficient to find that through a search engine that guides you to the appropriate government website.

     

    What’s the difference between a database, a search engine, and Wikipedia? 

    Databases

    Examples of databases include: Proquest, Jstor, Gale etc.

    Databases are usually a collection of published journals and magazine articles, dissertations, reviews, and abstracts.

    The benefits of databases:

    • Purchased by the library
    • Search for information in an organized collection
    • More relevant results
    • Information is stable
    • Content is reviewed and recommended by librarians.

     

    What to look out for with databases:

    • Terminology and depth of articles may be difficult to understand
    • Information may be dated. Though, it helps to sort results by date.
    • Can be narrow in topic

     

     

    Search Engine

    Examples of search engines include: Google, Yahoo, Bing etc.

    Search engines utilize a computer program to search the internet and identify items that match the characters and keywords entered by a user.

    The benefits of search engines:

    • Free to anyone with computer access
    • Useful for finding information on groups and organizations
    • Useful for finding personal web pages

    What to look out for with search engines:

    • No review standards with regard to content
    • Information not organized
    • Information not stable–locations and content continually change
    • Difficult to narrow down results
    • Difficult to assess legitimacy of information

     

     

    Wikipedia

    Wikipedia is a free online encyclopedia with entries that can be created, added, and edited by anyone.

    The benefits of Wikipedia:

    • Good for gathering background information
    • Helps generate search terms
    • Readers can consult the Wikipedia bibliographies to find potential sources.

    What to look out for on Wikipedia:

    • Because content is user-created and has no mandatory review process, there is no guarantee the information is reliable
    • Authors are not required to provide credentials
    • Pages recently edited or pages on controversial issues can be very biased.

    Google Scholar

    The benefits of Google Scholar:

    • Indexes a wide range of scholarly literature
    • Searching is free 
    • Easy to use if you're familiar with Google
    • Google algorithm ranks relevance for you
    • Can set up library access links in settings

    What to look for with Google Scholar

    • Can't search by subject area of material type 
    • No full-text access to most articles
    • Very limited filters 
    • Content not organized by experts 
    • No easy way to identify peer-reviewed sources

     

    What to Keep in Mind

    Always be sure to read your assignment carefully and be sure to ask your teacher if you are unsure what sources to consult.

    And if you are ever in doubt about the reliability and credibility of a resource or need assistance finding a proper resource, do not hesitate to ask your H.S. librarian!